Before we ever went on a Disney Cruise we went on the Carnival Destiny (which is now known as the Sunshine after a multi-million dollare facelift). I know Carnival gets a bad rap for some things, but they have really done a nice job with overhauling all of their ships. First off, the food compares nicely on both cruise lines so I would give that a wash. As far as the shows go, in my opinion, that isn't even close as DCL blows the competition away with their shows. I think the ports of call are obviously a wash as well because you can pretty much go to the same places, with the exception of